This is a long one. And might need to be categorized as a random rant. Nevertheless, here are my:
Top 10 Reasons I Love (and should probably stop) Watching Detective Shows:
10: Convenient Characters
Let’s face it, sometimes the plot would die if the show didn’t have that one character who was over-the-top angry, opinionated or unlikable.
I remember an episode of my favorite crime and punishment series where the judge was so grossly prejudiced toward the defense that he not only should have recused himself from the case, but should have never been a judge. Frankly, the whole story behind his appointment to the bench would have been highly suspect.
And yet, I had bought into the story so much, I hated him like I was supposed to.
Great TV drama right there.
9: New Terms that make me feel smart
Did you see up there? I used the word recused. And apparently, I used it correctly. (see proof here)
That didn’t come from my years of education at Harvard Law. NOPE. It came from my years of training at TV Law. Sadly, there is no degree program or accreditation to account for the vast knowledge I have gained for my time.
I am, however, fairly certain that all real detectives and attorneys are hugely grateful to the TV writing community for exposing so many untrained minds to words they can only partially use correctly. Surely it makes their jobs so much easier.
8: Hijinks
No matter what level of professionalism real life police require (or are expected to show), there is usually one person on these shows (detective or detective consultant) who plays around, ‘messes’ with people’s heads and is generally an embarrassment to any officer – real or pretend.
But, they are so much smarter than everyone else that the world (and the boss) will put up with their unrelenting crap because they are probably right.
7: Lots of lying
On many crime shows, you can be sure that most of the witnesses will be questioned two or even three times in a single episode.
The pragmatic reason, presumably, is that the main actors are paid so grossly that the budget only allows for a certain number of small roles. It must be easier (not to mention cheaper) to fill those with the same couple of folks and film all of their spots in one day.
The result is that you can be sure a number of people are lying or withholding during their first interview(s), leaving me to wonder which one “really done it“.
6: No one likes the cops
This one sort of goes along with the previous issue. But along with all of the lying, many of the characters in red shirts* are just plain-ol’ uncooperative. They see a badge and become defensive, angry and accusatory.
The rich lady doesn’t want her social status tarnished by stooping to deal with a horrid situation;
The drug dealer’s next door neighbor has nothing to do with anything, but just hates cops in general;
The victim’s father refuses to believe the police are competently searching for the killer.
The only people on these shows who are cooperative are the simpletons or those with nothing of value to add.
*For you non-nerdy folk, red shirts signify a disposable character on Star Trek – surely the one doomed to die; I therefore use the term to relate to any character who only appears in one episode of a show.
.
5: Huh? What? I’m being followed?
Thankfully nothing really bad has happened to me, but I have been followed before. And after only 3 1/2 blocks, I was aware that someone was back there.
It’s called using your rear-view mirrors.
But if you are on a police drama, chances are, you – the trained detective whose job it is to notice things – will probably be oblivious to that car which has been directly behind you for the last mile and a half and isn’t even trying to disguise the pursuit.
4: Evidence-Schmevidence
I love the way the police muck up evidence by putting their hands all over it; picking things up and waving them around long before the forensics unit comes (Hawaii Five-uh oh).
How about planting a playing card on a dead body – like that wouldn’t destroy any case they have against any suspect.
What? Of course no one else could have committed the murder. There was a playing card was found in the pocket of the victim? Oh, that playing card. It has nothing to do with the case. You see, it was put onto the body by our handsome, yet obnoxious consultant.
Reasonable doubt? Never heard of it.
3: Freakishly Strong Females

Vest / Vest / Vest / Bullet-proof cop
Female officers on TV are just like most other females in Hollywood. They weigh about 12 1/2 pounds. But you can be sure that she can take down any AK-wielding, Glock-waving, knife brandishing, 200 pound suspect on her own. And he’ll probably have some bruised ribs and a shiner to remind him never to mess with her again.
Never fear, no one would press charges against her. After all, she is a girl.
2: That one guy is never wrong
While this is not the case with all crime shows, there have been a large number of detective series that include one character that is magically never, ever wrong.
Oh, of course there was that one crime he could never solve that caused him to go rogue or be unfulfilled or need serious therapy – for which he has substituted the consolation of getting all the other bad guys. Of course this is never enough and he remains obsessed with the one bad guy in the history of his life who alluded capture; thus making him a tragic hero.
Rest assured, however, that in this series, he will never be wrong. In fact, he will never be wrong again. At some point, he will even be able to resolve his long-held angst by catching that last criminal and therefore making the rest of his life dull and meaningless with nothing else to strive for because now he really is perfect.
And my number 1 reason I love (and should probably stop) watching detective shows:
1: Back-up is for sissies
Enough Said.
.
But, as long as I get to look at my husband and say, “I would totally make a better cop than that guy;” whether or not I should, I will go on watching detective shows.
And I will love every minute of it.
Like this:
Be the first to like this post.